Over The Rail Sportfishing
Home
Trips & Rates
Gallery
Reviews
Fishing & Hunting Reports
Meet the Captain

Learn More

My Trips

  1. All Trips
  2. /Private Trips
Premier Lake Ontario Fishing | Pulaski Charters
Premier Lake Ontario Fishing | Pulaski Charters
A person fishing in NY
Six cutthroat trout, chinook salmon, and lake trout in a scenic location in NY
Three Chinook Salmon caught fishing in NY
Two coho and chinook salmon in NY
Three Chinook salmon caught while fishing in NY
Rainbow Trout caught fishing in NY
5 Chinook Salmon caught while fishing in Pulaski
Two anglers fishing in NY
3 people enjoying fishing and hunting in NY
Two anglers fishing in Pulaski
BOOK THIS TRIP
TRENDING NOW

Premier Lake Ontario Fishing | Pulaski Charters

locationNew York

What you will be catching:

  • Brown TroutBrown Trout
  • Chinook SalmonChinook Salmon
  • Coho SalmonCoho Salmon
  • Lake TroutLake Trout
  • Steelhead TroutSteelhead Trout
  • This 6-hour afternoon charter on Lake Ontario puts you right in the heart of some of New York's best salmon and trout fishing. Captain Justin Irving knows these waters around Pulaski like the back of his hand, and he'll have you set up with quality rods, tackle, and bait from the moment you step aboard at 1 PM. The afternoon timing works perfectly
  • you'll hit the water when fish are active and still have your morning free. With space for up to 4 anglers, it's ideal for families or small groups wanting a solid day on the water without the full-day commitment. Just bring your fishing license, some snacks, and get ready to target some serious trophy fish in one of the Great Lakes' most productive fishing spots.

Trip Pricing and Availabilities:

Trip pricing information is temporarily unavailable.

Lake Ontario Afternoon Fishing Adventure

If you're looking for a solid half-day fishing trip that won't eat up your whole day, Captain Justin Irving's 6-hour afternoon charter on Lake Ontario is exactly what you need. Launching from Pulaski at 1:00 PM, this trip gives you the perfect window to target some of the lake's best salmon and trout species while still having your morning free. With all gear provided and space for up to 4 anglers, it's a customer favorite for good reason - you get world-class fishing without the early morning wake-up call that comes with dawn trips.

What to Expect on the Water

This 6-hour window hits some of the most productive fishing times on Lake Ontario. The afternoon bite can be absolutely phenomenal, especially when the morning boat traffic dies down and fish start moving again. Captain Justin knows these waters like the back of his hand, and he'll put you on the fish using proven techniques and top-rated equipment. The boat heads out into the deeper waters where the big salmon and trout cruise, and you'll spend your time working the best spots based on current conditions. All rods, reels, bait, and tackle are included, so you just need to bring your New York fishing license, some snacks, and drinks to keep you going. The relaxed afternoon vibe makes this trip perfect for families, groups of friends, or anyone who wants to experience Lake Ontario fishing without committing to a full day.

Trolling the Deep Waters

Lake Ontario fishing is all about trolling, and Captain Justin has this technique dialed in perfectly. You'll be running multiple lines at different depths using downriggers and planer boards to cover maximum water. The boat stays moving at just the right speed to present your lures naturally to cruising fish. Spoons, plugs, and flasher-fly combinations are the go-to setups here, and the captain adjusts colors and depths based on what's working that day. The fish finder is constantly running, looking for bait schools and temperature breaks where the action heats up. When a fish hits, you'll know it - these Lake Ontario salmon and trout don't mess around. The drag will scream, and you'll get a real fight on your hands. The captain coaches you through the whole process, from setting the hook to landing your fish.

Species You'll Want to Hook

Coho Salmon are absolute rockets when they hit your line. These silver bullets typically run 8-15 pounds and are known for their acrobatic fights - expect multiple jumps and screaming runs that'll test your skills. Peak season runs from late spring through early fall, and they love chasing baitfish in the upper water column. What makes cohos so exciting is their unpredictability - they might hit hard and fast, or they might follow your lure for what feels like forever before deciding to strike.

Steelhead Trout are the ultimate test of an angler's patience and skill. These chrome-bright fighters average 6-12 pounds but can push much larger, and they're famous for their long, powerful runs and stubborn fighting style. Spring and fall offer the best steelhead action, when they're moving between deep water and tributary areas. They're incredibly line-shy and can be finicky about presentations, but when you hook into a steelhead, you'll understand why they're considered one of the premier sport fish in the Great Lakes.

Chinook Salmon are the kings of Lake Ontario for good reason. These massive fish regularly hit 20-30 pounds and can go even bigger during peak runs. They're most active from late spring through early fall, and they prefer the deeper, cooler waters where Captain Justin likes to focus his efforts. Chinooks are bulldogs - they don't jump much, but they'll pull hard and deep, testing your tackle and your endurance. Landing a big king salmon is a bucket-list experience that keeps anglers coming back year after year.

Brown Trout are the smartest fish in the lake, hands down. They're incredibly wary and often require finesse presentations to fool them. These golden-flanked beauties typically range from 5-15 pounds and are most active during low-light periods, making afternoon trips perfect timing. Browns are known for their powerful runs and their ability to find structure to wrap your line around. They're also some of the best eating fish in the lake, with firm, flavorful meat that's perfect for the dinner table.

Lake Trout are the deep-water specialists that can really surprise you with their size. These native fish live in the coldest, deepest parts of Lake Ontario and can reach impressive weights - 10-20 pounders are common, with much larger fish possible. They're most active during cooler months and tend to fight deep, making long, steady runs rather than flashy jumps. Lake trout have a unique flavor and are highly prized by anglers who appreciate their prehistoric appearance and hard-fighting nature.

Time to Book Your Spot

This afternoon charter strikes the perfect balance between serious fishing and flexible scheduling. You get 6 full hours on some of the most productive waters in the Great Lakes, targeting multiple species with a captain who knows how to put you on fish. The 1:00 PM start time means you can sleep in, grab lunch, and still get out for prime afternoon fishing. With all tackle provided and space for 4 anglers, it's an ideal choice for anyone looking to experience what Lake Ontario fishing is all about. Don't wait - the best fishing days fill up fast, and you don't want to miss your chance to hook into some of these legendary Great Lakes fish.

Learn more about the species

Brown Trout

Brown trout are the crafty veterans of Lake Ontario - golden-brown backs covered in black spots with that distinctive orange adipose fin. They average 2-8 pounds but can reach double digits, especially the lake-run fish that get fat on alewives. Browns are notorious for being finicky and prefer structure like drop-offs, weed lines, and rocky points. They really turn on during fall when water temps drop, feeding aggressively at dawn and dusk. Many consider them the best eating trout with firm, mild flesh. What makes browns challenging is their wariness - they'll inspect your offering and often refuse obvious presentations. During summer, they go deep with the thermocline, but spring and fall bring them shallow. My trick: when browns are being picky, downsize your lures and slow your trolling speed - sometimes subtle is what triggers these educated fish.

Brown Trout

Chinook Salmon

Chinook salmon, the "kings" of the Great Lakes, are the heavyweights you're after - typically 15-30 pounds with some pushing 40+. These silver-sided bruisers have black spots on their backs, tails, and even inside their mouths, plus that distinctive black gum line. Kings are light-sensitive, so they hang deep during bright days, often 60-100 feet down in summer. They're most active in low light conditions - early morning, evening, or overcast days. What guests love about kings is the sheer power - these fish will strip line and test your drag like nothing else. The meat is rich and oily, perfect for grilling or smoking. Here's my go-to trick: when kings are deep, use a dodger and spoon combo trolled just above bottom - the extra flash and vibration triggers strikes from even the most stubborn fish.

Chinook Salmon

Coho Salmon

Coho salmon, also called "silvers," are pure acrobats that'll jump up to 6 feet out of the water when hooked. These fish typically run 8-12 pounds and 12-30 inches, with that classic silver body and dark blue-green back dotted with black spots. They're famous for their bright orange-red meat and aggressive fighting style. In Lake Ontario, cohos cruise the deeper waters during summer but move closer to shore in fall as they prepare to spawn. Early morning and evening tend to be your best bets, especially when the water's a bit choppy. They'll hit spoons, plugs, and flies trolled at various depths. Here's a local tip: when you hook one, keep steady pressure but don't horse it - let them tire themselves out with those spectacular jumps, and you'll land more fish.

Coho Salmon

Lake Trout

Lake trout are the deep-water giants of the Great Lakes, typically running 15-40 pounds with some monsters over 50. These grey-green fish with cream-colored spots love the coldest, deepest water - often 80-150 feet down during summer. They're built for the depths with that torpedo shape and prefer low-light conditions. Lakers are scrappy fighters that use their weight and the deep water to their advantage, making long, powerful runs toward bottom. The meat is rich and oily, great smoked or grilled. Spring right after ice-out and fall are prime times when they move shallower. During summer, you'll need downriggers to reach them in the thermocline. Here's what works: jig aggressively with large spoons or soft plastics - lakers like aggressive presentations that mimic wounded baitfish, and don't be afraid to work them vertically right under the boat.

Lake Trout

Steelhead Trout

Steelhead are rainbow trout that decided to live large - these chrome-bright fighters average 24 inches but can push 45 inches and over 30 pounds. Unlike their rainbow cousins that stay in streams, steelhead spend years in the big water, getting strong and silver. They're the same species but built like athletes. These fish prefer cooler water and often hold near structure like drop-offs, points, and current breaks. Fall through spring is prime time, especially during overcast conditions when they're more active. What makes steelhead special is their endurance - they'll make long, powerful runs and jump repeatedly. The fight can last 10-15 minutes with a good fish. Pro tip: when targeting steelhead, focus on the thermocline where the water temperature drops - that's where they'll be stacked during warmer months.

Steelhead Trout

About the Penn Yan 265 Pro Hunter

Company vehicle

Vehicle Guest Capacity: 6

Manufacturer Name: Mercruiser

Maximum Cruising Speed: 30

Number of Engines: 1

Horsepower per Engine: 260

Captain Justin Irving's Lake Ontario charter boat offers the perfect afternoon escape for salmon and trout fishing in Pulaski's prime waters. This 6-hour trip departs at 1:00 PM, giving you plenty of time to target trophy fish while the afternoon bite heats up. The boat comfortably handles up to 4 anglers, making it ideal for small groups or families wanting a more intimate fishing experience. All your fishing gear is provided - rods, reels, bait, and tackle are ready to go. Just bring your New York fishing license, some snacks, and your favorite drinks for the trip. Captain Justin knows these Lake Ontario waters like the back of his hand and will put you on the best spots for salmon and trout action. The afternoon timing works great if you're not an early riser or want to enjoy a leisurely morning before heading out. Lake Ontario's consistent afternoon fishing means you'll have solid chances at landing some serious fish while enjoying the beautiful scenery around Pulaski.
Over The Rail Sportfishing

Follow Us

FacebookInstagram

Navigate

Home

Trips & Rates

Gallery

Reviews

Fishing & Hunting Reports

Meet the Captain

FAQ - Fishing

Contact Us

FEATURED

Merch Store

Things To Do

Gift Card

Fishing License

Ice Catch

Lake Fun

Lake Angling

Lake Reels

Lake Rush

Reel in big on New York's waters!

Over The Rail Sportfishing is based out of the World Famous Salmon River in Pulaski, NY. We target Salmon, Brown Trout, Lake Trout, Steelhead, Walleye, Northern Pike and Yellow Perch. We also provide Guided Ice fishing trips as well as Guided Hunting trips for Turkey, Black Bear, and Whitetail Deer. Book your trips today!

More about Over The Rail Sportfishing

© Copyright 2026. All rights reserved.

Powered by Guidesly

Privacy Policy

Sitemap