Over The Rail Sportfishing
Home
Trips & Rates
Gallery
Reviews
Fishing & Hunting Reports
Meet the Captain

Learn More

My Trips

Expert Lake Ontario Fishing Charters | World-Class

  • Published Date: July 22, 2025
  • Fishing
  • New York
  • $350 - $750 price range
  • Updated Date: September 25, 2025

Summary

Hop aboard with Over The Rail Sportfishing for a 4-hour Lake Ontario adventure. You'll be trolling the waters for impressive catches like salmon and trout. This trip is great for anglers of all skill levels - from first-timers to seasoned pros. The crew provides all the fishing gear you'll need, so just bring your license, some snacks, and drinks. Lake Ontario offers some world-class fishing opportunities, and you'll get to experience them firsthand. The stunning lake views add to the experience as you wait for that big bite. With a max of 4 guests, you'll get plenty of personal attention from the guides. They'll share local knowledge and help you improve your technique. Whether you're after a new personal best or just want to enjoy a day on the water, this charter delivers. It's a perfect way to spend a half-day experiencing the best of Lake Ontario fishing.
Expert Lake Ontario Fishing Charters | World-Class

Big Lake, Big Fish

previous-image
Fishing at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina, jigging and trolling techniques

Partly cloudy skies set the stage for a perfect day of jigging and trolling!

Sea and Rainbow Trout fishing at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina using jigging technique

Brown trout cooperated!

Rainbow Trout fishing in Pulaski NY, jigging technique

Huge Rainbow Trout hooked on a perfect afternoon in Pulaski!

Fishing in Pulaski NY with jigging, trolling, and ice fishing techniques

Clearing skies promise the best fishing ahead in Pulaski!

Large salmon caught fishing on boat deck with equipment in Pulaski NY

Nice salmon haul using multiple techniques in Pulaski!

Large salmon catch on boat deck with fishing equipment at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina

Exciting salmon fishing adventure with multiple catch using jigging and trolling techniques!

Fishing boat on blue water with rainbow trout caught using jigging and trolling techniques at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina

Great day on the water with rainbow trout using jigging and trolling at Salmon River!

Coho salmon displayed on wooden dock at fishing center marina in Pulaski NY

Nice coho salmon caught using jigging and trolling techniques at the marina.

Chinook salmon catch displayed on wooden boards at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina fishing dock

Great day jigging for Chinook salmon at the marina!

Row of caught Chinook salmon laid out on ground at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina fishing center

Great day of Chinook salmon fishing using jigging and trolling techniques at the marina!

Fishing at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina, jigging and trolling techniques

Partly cloudy skies set the stage for a perfect day of jigging and trolling!

Sea and Rainbow Trout fishing at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina using jigging technique

Brown trout cooperated!

Rainbow Trout fishing in Pulaski NY, jigging technique

Huge Rainbow Trout hooked on a perfect afternoon in Pulaski!

Fishing in Pulaski NY with jigging, trolling, and ice fishing techniques

Clearing skies promise the best fishing ahead in Pulaski!

Large salmon caught fishing on boat deck with equipment in Pulaski NY

Nice salmon haul using multiple techniques in Pulaski!

Large salmon catch on boat deck with fishing equipment at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina

Exciting salmon fishing adventure with multiple catch using jigging and trolling techniques!

Fishing boat on blue water with rainbow trout caught using jigging and trolling techniques at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina

Great day on the water with rainbow trout using jigging and trolling at Salmon River!

Coho salmon displayed on wooden dock at fishing center marina in Pulaski NY

Nice coho salmon caught using jigging and trolling techniques at the marina.

Chinook salmon catch displayed on wooden boards at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina fishing dock

Great day jigging for Chinook salmon at the marina!

Row of caught Chinook salmon laid out on ground at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina fishing center

Great day of Chinook salmon fishing using jigging and trolling techniques at the marina!

Fishing at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina, jigging and trolling techniques

Partly cloudy skies set the stage for a perfect day of jigging and trolling!

Sea and Rainbow Trout fishing at Salmon River Lighthouse & Marina using jigging technique

Brown trout cooperated!

Rainbow Trout fishing in Pulaski NY, jigging technique

Huge Rainbow Trout hooked on a perfect afternoon in Pulaski!

Fishing in Pulaski NY with jigging, trolling, and ice fishing techniques

Clearing skies promise the best fishing ahead in Pulaski!

next-image

Lake Ontario's Hottest Fishing Action

Ready to chase some of the biggest, baddest fish Lake Ontario has to offer? Hop aboard with Over The Rail Sportfishing for a 4-hour trolling adventure that'll have you hooked from start to finish. Whether you're a seasoned angler or it's your first time wetting a line, Captain Justin knows exactly where to find the trophy salmon and trout that make Lake Ontario famous. With all the gear provided and Justin's expert know-how, you're in for a world-class fishing experience right in your backyard.

What to Expect on the Water

As soon as you step on board, you'll feel the excitement buzzing in the air. Captain Justin will get you set up with top-notch trolling gear as you cruise out to his favorite honey holes. Keep your eyes peeled for diving birds and jumping fish – telltale signs that the bite is on! You'll be trolling with multiple lines out, covering different depths to target various species. When a rod goes off, it's all hands on deck for an adrenaline-pumping fight. There's nothing quite like the scream of the reel when a monster King salmon takes the bait!

Trolling Tactics & Top Gear

On this trip, we'll be using the tried-and-true method of trolling to cover lots of water and entice those big lake predators. Captain Justin rigs up a spread of downriggers, dipsy divers, and planer boards to present a buffet of lures at different depths. You might see flashy spoons, cut bait rigs, or even whole herring depending on what's hot that day. The captain constantly tweaks speed, depth, and lure selection based on water temperature, clarity, and fish activity. It's a real art form, and you'll be learning from one of the best in the business.

Customer Stories

"I don't think there's words to say how great of a trip we had. Once we started gearing up to fish, we were on fish. Cap. Justin was very knowledgeable with the area, how and where we needed our lures, and most importantly how to not lose a fish. We will definitely be coming back for future trips. This was our first trip on Lake Ontario and I feel the best we could ever have." - Brian

"Captain Justin at Over the Rail was absolutely outstanding! We were a party of 5 adults and Justin worked tirelessly for 8 hours straight to make sure we had the best Salmon fishing trip ever. From the first minute to the last, Justin worked at keeping the rigs loaded, changed lures and bait as needed, monitored our location to find the best spots for fish and gave us non stop narrative and information that was both informative and helpful. We ended up landing 2 HUGE King Salmon, a huge Steelhead, and 5 medium King Salmon!!! We had the best take of the day and brought home a big cooler full of deliciousness. Justin runs a great, one man operation and we would highly recommend him for your trip." - vikki

"My 8year old Grandson and I had a wonderful and successful fishing trip with Captain Justin. Captain Justin explained everything in detail for my Grandson. He talked to him about the species of fish, how to rig the lines, different speeds and water temperatures to catch different species of fish. We limited out on Lake Trout and had 2 salmon in the boat in just under 4 hours. My Grandson's arms got tire of reeling in fish, so we cut our trip a little short. My Grandson was so excited that we came home and have booked another trip with Captain Justin for later this season. His deck hand Cooper(dog) is great with kids. My Grandson and I highly recommend Captain Justin and Over the Rail Sportfishing. Thank you again Captain Justin. Mark & Victor" - Mark

Target Species Breakdown

Coho Salmon: These silver bullets are known for their acrobatic fights and delicious meat. Typically weighing 3-8 pounds, Cohos are most active in the spring and fall. They're often found closer to the surface, making for some heart-pounding topwater action. Anglers love targeting Cohos for their aggressive strikes and the way they'll tail-walk across the water when hooked.

Chinook (King) Salmon: The crown jewel of Lake Ontario, Chinooks are the largest salmon species in the Great Lakes. These brutes can top 30 pounds and put up a brutal fight that'll test your arms and your gear. They're most abundant from July through September as they stage for their spawning run. Landing a monster King is the ultimate trophy for many Lake Ontario anglers.

Steelhead Trout: If you're after a high-flying, hard-fighting fish, look no further than the steelhead. These chrome-bright rainbows are known for their spectacular aerial displays and blistering runs. They can be caught year-round but are especially active in the cooler months. Steelhead in the 5-15 pound range are common, with some topping 20 pounds.

Brown Trout: Lake Ontario's brown trout fishery is world-class, with fish regularly topping 10 pounds. These wary predators are often found cruising the shallows in spring and fall, making for some exciting near-shore action. Browns are prized for their beautiful spotting and their hard-fighting nature.

Lake Trout: The native giants of Lake Ontario, lake trout can live for decades and grow to massive proportions. While they're typically targeted in deeper water, trophy "lakers" will move shallow in the spring and fall. These powerful fish often require heavy gear and put up a dogged fight all the way to the net.

Time to Book Your Spot

Whether you're dreaming of battling a trophy King salmon or filling the cooler with tasty Cohos, this 4-hour Lake Ontario charter with Over The Rail Sportfishing is your ticket to an unforgettable day on the water. Captain Justin's local knowledge, top-notch gear, and passion for putting clients on fish make this trip a can't-miss experience for anglers of all skill levels. Don't forget to bring your camera – you'll want proof when you're telling fish stories about the monsters you hauled in! Spots fill up fast, especially during peak salmon season, so don't wait to lock in your date. Get ready to make some waves and create lasting memories on beautiful Lake Ontario!

Customer Reviews

Crappy Day Success

quotes

Was a very good trip always like fishing with justin. Was a crappy day and we still pulled it off.will ne back in the fall.

VY
victor yeaton

June 1, 2025

Lake Ontario Dream

quotes

I don’t think there’s words to say how great of a trip we had. Once we started gearing up to fish, we were on fish. Cap. Justin was very knowledgeable with the area, how and where we needed our lures, and most importantly how to not lose a fish. We will definitely be coming back for future trips. This was our first trip on Lake Ontario and I feel the best we could ever have.

Read More
BD
Brian Daniels

July 24, 2024

Justin Outdid Again

quotes

another fantastic trip with justin you outdid yourself from last year thanks again, Mike, brian and Tommy see you next year!

ML
MICHAEL LANGER

August 25, 2025

Justin Finds Fish

quotes

Justin worked HARD to ensure a successful trip. he's fully engaged and does everything he can to find fish and coolers.

RC
Robert Chambers

July 28, 2025

Grandson Fishing Fun

quotes

My 8year old Grandson and I had a wonderful and successful fishing trip with Captain Justin. Captain Justin explained everything in detail for my Grandson. He talked to him about the species of fish, how to rig the lines, different speeds and water temperatures to catch different species of fish. We limited out on Lake Trout and had 2 salmon in the boat in just under 4 hours. My Grandson's arms got tire of reeling in fish, so we cut our trip a little short. My Grandson was so excited that we came home and have booked another trip with Captain Justin for later this season. His deck hand Cooper(dog) is great with kids. My Grandson and I highly recommend Captain Justin and Over the Rail Sportfishing. Thank you again Captain Justin. Mark & Victor

Read More
MR
Mark Robertson

June 28, 2025

Justin Works Hard

quotes

Great day, Justin is a great guide, works hard to put us on fish and is a pleasure to fish with

JO
jim orr

July 15, 2025

Limit in Three Hours

quotes

An exceptional day with Captain Justin. Caught our limit in three hours, with a high percentage of boated to total bites.

JO
jim orr

September 12, 2025

Salmon Bonanza

quotes

Captain Justin at Over the Rail was absolutely outstanding! We were a party of 5 adults and Justin worked tirelessly for 8 hours straight to make sure we had the best Salmon fishing trip ever. From the first minute to the last, Justin worked at keeping the rigs loaded, changed lures and bait as needed, monitored our location to find the best spots for fish and gave us non stop narrative and information that was both informative and helpful. We ended up landing 2 HUGE King Salmon, a huge Steelhead, and 5 medium King Salmon!!! We had the best take of the day and brought home a big cooler full of deliciousness. Justin runs a great, one man operation and we would highly recommend him for your trip.

Read More
VS
vikki skarzynski

July 27, 2025

Pro Justin Delivers

quotes

we had a great time, he is very professional. I definitely would recommend Justin to everyone.

RH
Randy Houle

September 18, 2025

quotes

Let me just say that the waves were choppy and both My Husband and I got motion sickness(bummer, we forgot to take meds for it!) But of course that wasn’t Captain Justin’s fault. He was very knowledgeable and answered all our questions. We felt comfortable and right at home! We will definitely be coming back for more and we refuse to be out there with anyone else! Thank you Captain Justin👍

Read More
JL
Jessica Lopez

July 19, 2022

Fish Chat Relax

quotes

Great captain to fish with! Highly recommended if you’re looking for a great outing, not just with the fishing but also the relaxation and great conversations!

PR
Preston Robbins

June 25, 2023

Cant Wait for More

quotes

We couldn't have asked for a better day! Or a better captain! Can't wait to go again next year

BL
Brian LaDue

September 11, 2022

Number One Captain

quotes

#1 captain in my book. Highly recommended!

DP
David Pauska

July 24, 2023

Storm Gang Favorite

quotes

Justin is THE BEST Captain! He is informative, honest and very knowledgeable on fishing and the lake. He also is concerned about making sure we have fun and goes above and beyond to get you fish to bring back. 5 stars all the way around for excellence! See you again next year Captain Justin!! Love from the "storm gang"

Read More
DO
Debbie Oliveri

August 17, 2023

Superior Knowledge

quotes

Excellent July trip. Capt Justin has superior knowledge of the fishery, works hard to find the fish, and delivers with professionalism and a sense of humor. Highly recommended.

GH
Greg Hazley

July 26, 2024

Justin Tries It All

quotes

The fish werent biteing much but Captain Justin threw everything at it and we managed to get some meat in the locker. I would highly reccomend using his service very polite easy to work with and explains how and why rods are rigged certain ways. I cant say enough good things HIGHLY RECCOMEND.

Read More
RP
Ronald Peck

August 15, 2024

Future with Justin

quotes

I met Justin he was a tremendous sincere person but the day of the trip unfortunately he had boat troubles.We were only there for the day because of work work schedules unfortunately.He tried his best to accommodate us so set us up with Shane owns My way boat and salmon river guide service.Shane was by worst the rudest guide I have ever met and I have been around the world. I look forward to fishing with Justin in the future.

Read More
EC
Eric Cooper

September 19, 2024

Fish to Table Trip

quotes

Captain Justin took us to the fish! We enjoyed fresh salmon that night for dinner and taking some home. Justin was happy to share his knowledge on salmon fishing and the charter industry, made for a nice day!

DP
Doug Painter

September 21, 2024

Learn more about the species

Brown Trout

Brown trout are the clever lurkers of Lake Ontario. These golden-brown beauties average 5-10 pounds but can reach 20+. They're often found near shore structures like drop-offs and weed beds. Spring and fall are prime seasons, but summer nights can be hot too. Browns are prized for their wariness and hard fights - fooling a big one is a real accomplishment. Their buttery, orange flesh makes great table fare as well. To target browns, try trolling or casting near shore with stickbaits or spoons that mimic baitfish. A local secret is to fish cloudy days or low-light periods when they're more active. Browns can be particular, so varying your presentation is key. Don't be afraid to go big - trophy browns often prefer larger lures. When you hook one, be ready for some tricky maneuvers as they try to wrap you around structure.

Brown Trout

Chinook Salmon

Chinook salmon, or "kings," are the giants of Lake Ontario. These bruisers can top 30 pounds, with 15-20 pounders common. They prefer cool, deep waters but come shallow to feed. Late summer and early fall are prime as they prep for their spawning run. Chinooks are famous for their strong fights - when one hits, hold on tight! Anglers love targeting them for the challenge and their rich, flavorful meat. To find kings, look for bait schools on your fish finder. They often suspend in the thermocline. Downriggers with flashers and cut bait or large spoons are go-to setups. A local tip: troll slower in cold water, faster when it's warm. Keep your drag set light at first - these fish make blistering runs. Landing a trophy Chinook is a real accomplishment and will leave you with sore arms and a big smile.

Chinook Salmon

Coho Salmon

Coho salmon are a real treat to catch in Lake Ontario. These silver-sided fighters usually run 8-12 pounds, though some can top 20. Look for them in cooler, deeper waters, especially near structure. They're most active in fall as they prepare to spawn, but summer can be hot too. Cohos are known for their acrobatic leaps and hard-fighting spirit - they'll give you a run for your money on light tackle. The meat is bright orange and delicious, making them popular for the dinner table too. To up your odds, try trolling with flashy spoons or cut herring at various depths. These fish have great eyesight, so using attractors like dodgers can really make your lure stand out. When you hook one, hang on tight and enjoy the ride!

Coho Salmon

Lake Trout

Lake trout are the deep-water giants of Ontario. These big, grey-green predators can top 30 pounds, with 10-20 pounders common. They love cold, well-oxygenated depths, often hanging out 50-100 feet down. Spring and fall are prime when they come shallower, but you can catch them year-round. Lakers are known for their powerful, dogged fights - they won't jump, but they'll test your arms. Their rich, oily flesh is great smoked or grilled. To find them, look for underwater humps or drop-offs on your chart. Jigging or trolling with downriggers are go-to methods. Try large spoons, cut bait, or jigs that imitate cisco or alewives. A local tip: glow-in-the-dark lures can be deadly in deep water. When you hook up, be patient - lake trout fights are marathons, not sprints. Landing a big laker is a true trophy and a taste of the Great Lakes' wild history.

Lake Trout

Steelhead Trout

Steelhead are the adrenaline junkies of Lake Ontario. These sea-run rainbows average 5-10 pounds but can push 20. They're lightning fast and love to jump, making for an exciting fight. You'll find them in cooler waters, often near tributary mouths or along shoreline drop-offs. Spring and fall are prime seasons when they're running, but you can catch them year-round. Steelhead are prized for their hard-fighting nature and tasty, pink flesh. They can be finicky, so matching your presentation to what they're feeding on is key. Try drifting egg sacs or swinging flies in current seams. A local trick is to use light, nearly invisible fluorocarbon leaders - these fish have sharp eyes and can be leader shy. Whether you're a fly fisher or gear angler, hooking into a chrome-bright steelhead is an experience you won't soon forget.

Steelhead Trout

About the Penn Yan 265 Pro Hunter

Company vehicle

Vehicle Guest Capacity: 6

Manufacturer Name: Mercruiser

Maximum Cruising Speed: 30

Number of Engines: 1

Horsepower per Engine: 260

Ready to reel in some big ones on Lake Ontario? Hop aboard our comfy fishing boat for a 4-hour adventure on the water. We'll cruise out to the prime fishing spots where salmon and trout are biting. Whether you're a seasoned angler or trying fishing for the first time, our experienced crew will make sure you have a blast. We provide all the gear you need - just bring your excitement and maybe some snacks. With room for 4 guests, it's perfect for a small group or family outing. Keep your eyes peeled for the stunning shoreline views as we troll for the catch of the day. Don't forget your camera to capture those proud moments when you land a whopper! A valid fishing license is required, so be sure to grab one before you come. Book your spot now for a fantastic day of fishing on beautiful Lake Ontario!
Over The Rail Sportfishing

Follow Us

FacebookInstagram

Navigate

Home

Trips & Rates

Gallery

Reviews

Fishing & Hunting Reports

Meet the Captain

FAQ - Fishing

Contact Us

FEATURED

Merch Store

Things To Do

Gift Card

Fishing License

Ice Catch

Lake Fun

Lake Angling

Lake Reels

Lake Rush

Reel in big on New York's waters!

Over The Rail Sportfishing is based out of the World Famous Salmon River in Pulaski, NY. We target Salmon, Brown Trout, Lake Trout, Steelhead, Walleye, Northern Pike and Yellow Perch. We also provide Guided Ice fishing trips as well as Guided Hunting trips for Turkey, Black Bear, and Whitetail Deer. Book your trips today!

More about Over The Rail Sportfishing

© Copyright 2025. All rights reserved.

Powered by Guidesly

Privacy Policy

Sitemap