Over The Rail Sportfishing Customer Reviews

Ratings & Reviews Summary -

5.007 Reviews
out of 5
Based on 7 ratings
Based on 7 recommendations

We’re best known for…

Great Guide
Best Spots
Best Boat
Good with Kids


August 17, 2023
Trip taken August 15, 2023

Justin is THE BEST Captain! He is informative, honest and very knowledgeable on fishing and the lake. He also is concerned about making sure we have fun and goes above and beyond to get you fish to bring back. 5 stars all the way around for excellence! See you again next year Captain Justin!! Love from the "storm gang"

Read More


July 24, 2023
Trip taken July 21, 2023

#1 captain in my book. Highly recommended!



June 25, 2023Show Reply
Trip taken June 25, 2023

Great captain to fish with! Highly recommended if you’re looking for a great outing, not just with the fishing but also the relaxation and great conversations!



September 11, 2022Show Reply
Trip taken September 11, 2022

We couldn't have asked for a better day! Or a better captain! Can't wait to go again next year


Matt Laverack

September 6, 2022
Trip taken September 6, 2022

Awesome time with justin, owner of over the rail. Very knowledgable and great attitude. 5 stars all the way! Will he booking next years trip very soon.


Jessica Lopez

July 19, 2022Show Reply
Trip taken July 19, 2022

Let me just say that the waves were choppy and both My Husband and I got motion sickness(bummer, we forgot to take meds for it!) But of course that wasn’t Captain Justin’s fault. He was very knowledgeable and answered all our questions. We felt comfortable  and right at home! We will definitely be coming back for more and we refuse to be out there with anyone else! Thank you Captain Justin👍

Read More

Timothy Thomas

June 9, 2021
Trip taken June 9, 2021

Captain Justin took my family out for my bachelor party this past weekend, and I can't say enough about how great of a guide he is. My whole family can't stop talking about how much fun we had, and how we can not wait to go back. We truly had an experience that none of us will ever forget. Justin is very knowledgeable, patient, and works his butt off to make sure that your trip is successful. I'm so glad that we booked our trip with Over The Rail. I couldn't have asked for a better captain. Hopefully we see you again soon, Justin!

Read More

My Upcoming Availability

Select a Date

Build Your Trip Now

Experience Premier New York Fishing Charters

Over The Rail Sportfishing's Fishing and Hunting Business Reviews

Have you been looking for the best fishing and hunting experience around New York? Look no further than Over The Rail Sportfishing! With a reputation for excellence in both Lake Ontario fishing and Adirondack hunting, this business has been praised by customers far and wide. But don't just take our word for it - check out these customer reviews! One customer raved about their "amazing fishing trip with the knowledgeable and friendly staff." Another remarked on the "expertise of the guides" during their hunting excursion. These reviews are a testament to the dedication that Over The Rail Sportfishing has to providing top-notch experiences for its clients. But don't just trust a few reviews - there are countless positive comments about this business online. From satisfied customers praising their attentive service to repeat visitors who can't wait to come back, it's clear that Over The Rail Sportfishing is doing something right.